I think Neko said pretty much everything I had to say but I'll add a few more pointers. First of all, what difference does it make that people are or aren't active? Does it negatively impact the community? No. Members are just members, not mods (hence they don't need to be active), and I think that it is fair that people want to become member and end up just not playing for a while. So what? No harm no foul.
This pretty much speaks for itself.
And the notion that Indi's post about bsp having more than 10 hours somehow swayed people's opinion just makes no sense. It was a clarification to people that he had more than 10 hours so people wouldn't call him out for only having 45 minutes played. Simple as that.